The Whispers Book
By Ashley Audrain
Moderated by: Lorraine
The Loverlys sit by the hospital bed of their young son who is in a coma after falling from his bedroom window in the middle of the night; his mother, Whitney, will not speak to anyone. Back home, their friends and neighbors are left in shock, each confronting their own role in the events that led up to what happened that terrible night: the warm, altruistic Parks who are the Loverlys’ best friends; the young, ambitious Goldsmiths who are struggling to start a family of their own; and the quiet, elderly Portuguese couple who care for their adult son with a developmental disability, and who pass the long days on the front porch, watching their neighbors go about their busy lives.
The story spins out over the course of one week, in the alternating voices of the women in each family as they are forced to face the secrets within the walls of their own homes, and the uncomfortable truths that connect them all to one another. Set against the heartwrenching drama of what will happen to Xavier, who hangs between death and life, or a life changed forever, THE WHISPERS is a novel about what happens when we put our needs ahead of our children’s. Exploring the quiet sacrifices of motherhood, the intuitions that we silence, the complexities of our closest friendships, and the danger of envy, this is a novel about the reverberations of life’s most difficult decisions.
Source: goodreads
A message from the author.
Plot summary
The Whispers is a novel told from the rotating third-person limited perspective of four women—Whitney, Blair, Mara, and Rebecca—who live on the same street. The story begins with a man confessing to his wife that he’s been unfaithful, setting the stage for a series of secrets and betrayals.
A Child’s Fall and a Mother’s Shame
The main plot begins when Whitney’s son, Xavier, falls from a third-story window. He is placed in a coma, and much of the novel’s action takes place in the hospital as a guilt-ridden Whitney struggles with feelings of shame and responsibility. Flashbacks reveal her troubled relationship with her son, including a moment where she lost her temper and screamed at him in front of her neighbors.
Whitney feels like a failure as a mother, and her sense of inadequacy is intensified by her interactions with her neighbor, Blair, a stay-at-home mom who appears to love motherhood. Blair, in turn, feels her own life is unappreciated and envies Whitney’s. She begins to sneak into Whitney’s house, finding evidence that suggests her own husband, Aiden, is having an affair with Whitney. Blair’s suspicions eventually lead her to spread rumors about Whitney on neighborhood message boards.
Lives Unraveling
Meanwhile, the other neighbors are also struggling. Rebecca, a doctor, is coping with her fifth pregnancy after four miscarriages, which makes her feel like a failure. Her husband, Ben, asked her to stop trying for a child, but she lied to him to conceive. She hopes this pregnancy will be different. The only neighbor who seems to know her is Mara, an older woman whose marriage is miserable and who feels responsible for her son’s death. When her husband collapses, she waits for him to die before calling for help.
A shocking flashback reveals the truth about Xavier’s fall: he caught his mother, Whitney, having an affair with Ben—not Aiden. After a fight, Xavier had told Whitney he didn’t want to be her son, and Whitney said she would leave. He then went to his room and saw them having sex in the backyard. The sight caused him to lean out the window and fall.
The Aftermath and New Beginnings
As Xavier finally wakes up from his coma, he tells Whitney that he knows what happened and asks her what she’ll do now. The novel ends with the women facing the consequences of their secrets. Blair, despite her initial suspicions about her husband, returns to him. Mara regrets her interference in her neighbors’ lives. Rebecca suffers another miscarriage and confronts Ben about his infidelity, leaving him. The novel concludes with a glimmer of hope for her, as she is now free to pursue another way to become a mother.
To whom do you relate the most?
Character Analysis
Blair Parks
one of the novel’s main protagonists, is an insecure stay-at-home mother who regrets giving up her career. Despite her insecurities, she criticizes others, particularly her best friend, Whitney, highlighting the theme of female rivalry. She is also in denial about her own life, choosing to ignore the “whispers” of her intuition that her husband, Aiden, is being unfaithful. Blair’s character arc is defined by her fear of becoming like her mother, who silently suffered through her own husband’s indiscretions. Her reluctance to confront her problems, even as she feels she is “spiraling,” shows how she has absorbed the lesson that a “good woman” suffers in silence.
Aiden Parks
is Blair’s unfaithful husband. He is portrayed as an easygoing but unappreciative man who allows Blair to blame him for her frustrations. While Blair wrongly suspects him of having an affair with Whitney, he is actually a red herring, deflecting attention from the true affair between Whitney and Ben. Aiden’s infidelity and lies, coupled with Blair’s willful ignorance, tacitly teach their daughter, Chloe, a troubling lesson about what society expects of a “good woman.”
Whitney Loverly
is another central character and Blair’s best friend. She resents motherhood, viewing it as a “voluntary death” of a woman’s identity. Her last name, “Loverly,” hints at her true, dishonest nature. She is obsessed with appearances and uses her sexual relationships with men to feel in control and re-establish her dominance. She has an affair with Ben, a relationship that allows her to feel in control of her life even as she struggles to control others, especially her son, Xavier.
Jacob Loverly
is Whitney’s husband who, like Blair, chooses willful ignorance to cope with his unfaithful spouse. He knows about Whitney’s infidelity but chooses not to confront her, thereby becoming complicit in her dishonesty. He is more concerned with maintaining appearances and controlling the narrative around his family than with facing the truth. His refusal to acknowledge Whitney’s behavior and the events that led to their son’s fall ultimately defines their dysfunctional relationship.
Mara Alvaro
is an 82-year-old neighbor who embodies the old-school expectations of motherhood. She judges the younger women, Blair and Whitney, for failing to live up to her ideals. However, she is a hypocrite; she is a bitter woman consumed by a deep-seated resentment for her husband and her son’s death. She is a busybody who spies on her neighbors, meddling in their lives to gain a sense of control. She is also a killer, having allowed her husband to die to punish him for a past injustice.
Rebecca
is a doctor and one of the novel’s point-of-view characters. She is consumed by her desire for a child after four miscarriages, and her obsession with motherhood drives her to lie to her husband, Ben, about her cycle. Rebecca is unique among the women in the novel because she listens to her intuition and acts decisively when she discovers Ben’s infidelity. Her story illustrates how the mere possibility of motherhood can change a woman’s life and choices.
Book Pairing
Orange Wine
Aperol Spritz
Shock Top Beer
Buy the book:
Themes
Sacrifices of Motherhood
Every mother in the novel makes significant sacrifices, whether in her career, relationships, or sense of self. Blair gives up her career for motherhood, a choice that brings her joy but also leads to resentment and a feeling of social demotion. She feels that motherhood has made her less desirable to her husband and that her life has become “small and unimportant,” anxieties she pushes down to maintain a facade of a happy family. In contrast, Whitney resents motherhood and sacrifices her children for her career, which makes her feel in control. This choice, however, leaves her insecure about her mothering skills. Mara sacrifices her marriage to her devotion to her son and his death. This leads her to hide her true feelings from her husband and everyone else, and her identity becomes consumed by loss. Even Rebecca, who is not a mother, feels defined by her desire to be one. Her longing for a child makes her feel like a failure, and she sacrifices her integrity by lying to her husband about her pregnancy. Ultimately, the novel suggests that motherhood, or the desire for it, forces women to relinquish control over some aspect of their lives, leading to a diminished sense of self.
Effects of Willful Ignorance
Several characters in the novel choose willful ignorance as a coping mechanism, but their perceived control is an illusion. Blair ignores her intuition, her “whispers,” about her husband’s infidelity because the truth is too painful to accept. By choosing to believe her suspicions are just “paranoia,” she temporarily feels in control, but she also loses her intuition, setting up her daughter to repeat the same pattern of denial. Similarly, Jacob Loverly chooses to remain willfully ignorant of his wife’s affairs and verbal abuse of their son. He avoids confronting Whitney directly because he doesn’t want to know the truth. This willful ignorance allows him to maintain his “perfect” life and family, but it also allows the deception to fester, eventually leading to the near-death of his son. The novel suggests that while this denial may feel like a protective choice, it ultimately has devastating consequences.
Female Rivalry
The novel’s female characters are constantly in competition with each other, a rivalry that stems from their own insecurities and feelings of inadequacy. Blair and Whitney, in particular, engage in a constant rivalry, comparing their lives as a stay-at-home mother versus a career-driven one. While this competition makes them feel superior at times, it undermines the possibility of a genuine friendship. This rivalry isn’t just between the two of them; it extends to other women in the novel as well, as Blair judges other mothers and Mara judges both Blair and Whitney. The women’s criticisms of each other are simply reflections of sexist societal expectations about motherhood, appearance, and a woman’s role. This internalized misogyny ironically makes the women, whose shared experiences could unite them, instead turn on one another, creating relationships that are more damaging than supportive.
Bookclub questions
General Impressions
Many characters in the novel ignore their intuition, or their “whispers.” Why do you think they do this? What are they afraid of confronting?
How does Ashley Audrain’s portrayal of motherhood’s darker aspects in The Whispers compare to other books you’ve read on the topic? If you’ve read her debut novel, The Push, how does it explore similar themes of maternal ambivalence and societal pressure?
Which character’s perspective did you find most compelling, and what made their viewpoint particularly effective in conveying the novel’s themes of secrets and resentment?
Personal Reflection and Connection
Blair often compares herself to Whitney, a behavior rooted in her own insecurities. Have you ever found yourself comparing your life or choices to someone else’s? What do you think prompted that comparison, and what did you learn from the experience?
The characters in the novel choose willful ignorance to maintain a feeling of control. Can you recall a time when you ignored your own intuition? Why did you make that choice, and what were the consequences?
Whitney views motherhood as a “voluntary death” of identity, while Blair fully embraces it. Where do you fall on this spectrum of attitudes toward parenthood?
The characters often feel invisible in different ways. Can you relate to their feelings of being unseen, whether in their relationships or communities?
What family patterns have you found yourself either repeating or consciously breaking in your own life?
Societal and Cultural Context
The novel dramatizes the “Mommy Wars,” the cultural conflict between different approaches to motherhood. Where do you see this conflict playing out in contemporary society?
The gentrification of Mara’s neighborhood symbolizes a broader erasure of immigrant history. What similar patterns of cultural erasure do you see in communities today?
In what ways have societal expectations for mothers evolved in recent years, and do you think there has been real progress in how motherhood is discussed publicly?
Literary Analysis
How did the novel’s rotating third-person limited perspective affect your understanding of the story? What do multiple perspectives reveal about female rivalry that a single viewpoint couldn’t?
Think about the imagery related to consumption in the text. How is this imagery used to develop the novel’s themes of envy and self-destruction?
Xavier’s fall is both the inciting incident and the central mystery. How does this structure affect the story’s emotional impact and pacing?
Many characters repeat patterns from their upbringing. How does this generational repetition comment on the lasting impact of parental relationships and unhealed trauma?
Whitney’s attempt to suffocate her son is a shocking escalation of her character’s struggle. What does this scene reveal about her that wasn’t previously apparent?
Creative Engagement
If you were to write an epilogue set five years after the novel’s conclusion, what would have happened to each of the four women?
The paper airplanes Xavier sends to Mara become a key symbol of their connection. If you were to create another symbol to represent a relationship in the novel, what would it be?
Imagine you’re adapting The Whispers for a television show. Which scenes would you emphasize, and what visual motifs would you use to represent the characters’ ignored intuition?
Enjoy the reading!
You May Also Like
The Sanatorium by Sarah Pearse
The Surrogate Mother – by Freida McFadden
