Between The Wines Book Club
⭐ Monthly Pick Historical Fiction 2022

The Diamond Eye

By Kate Quinn
Moderated by BTW The Wines June 2022
Our Rating
★★★★
GenreHistorical Fiction
Pages435
PaceSlow
Club Vote4/5 Very Good
Who is Maud Dixon? — Book Cover

The Diamond Eye

by Kate Quinn

📅 Published: March 29, 2022 📍 Setting: Soviet Union, Russia
View on Amazon

The Diamond Eye by Kate Quinn — A Book That Will Stop You Cold

There are stories that entertain. And then there are stories that haunt you, that lodge themselves somewhere behind your ribs and refuse to leave.

The Diamond Eye is the second kind.

Before she was a legend, Lyudmila “Mila” Pavlichenko was just a young woman trying to hold her life together. A single mother. A history student. Someone who loved books and libraries and the quiet order of facts. In 1937 Kyiv, she built a modest, careful life and then Hitler invaded, and the world she knew was erased overnight.

What happened next is almost too extraordinary to believe. Except it’s true.

Given a rifle and sent to the front lines, Mila didn’t just survive the war, she became its most feared predator. Over three hundred confirmed kills. A name that made enemy soldiers flinch: Lady Death. And yet, beneath the legend, she remained what she had always been: a mother who wanted her son to grow up in a free world, a woman capable of devastating love and devastating loss, a reader who understood that history is written by whoever is left standing.

Kate Quinn, the New York Times bestselling author of The Rose Code, brings Mila’s story to life across two gripping timelines. One follows her transformation on the blood-soaked battlefields of the Eastern Front, where friendships are forged in fire and love arrives wearing a soldier’s uniform. The other drops us into the glittering, disorienting world of 1942 Washington, D.C., where Mila is sent on a propaganda tour she never asked for — wounded, grieving, and suddenly the target of a shadow she can’t quite see.

Because someone is watching Lady Death. Someone who doesn’t believe she is who they say she is. And he has a plan.

What unfolds is equal parts war story, love story, and assassination thriller, the kind of novel where you find yourself holding your breath on the subway or staying up past midnight because you cannot put it down. Mila’s world shifts between the frozen trenches of Sevastopol and the marble corridors of the White House, between the brutal clarity of the battlefield and the strange, perfumed unreality of American cocktail parties. And through it all, she carries her rifle, her grief, her secrets, and a diamond eye that misses nothing.

Then there is Eleanor Roosevelt, the last person you’d expect to become a wartime ally to a Soviet sniper. And yet their friendship, tender and unlikely and utterly real, is one of the most quietly moving things in a book full of extraordinary moments.

The Diamond Eye is not just a novel about a woman who went to war. It is a novel about what war costs, what it forges, and what it cannot take from you, no matter how hard it tries. It asks what we owe the people we love, what we owe ourselves, and whether a woman who has learned to kill can also learn to live.

The answer, when it comes, is hard-won and unforgettable.

Mila Pavlichenko was a real person. She really did pull that trigger 309 times. She really did walk into the White House. She really did change history.

And now, finally, she gets the story she deserves.

In 1937 in the snowbound city of Kiev (now known as Kyiv), wry and bookish history student Mila Pavlichenko organizes her life around her library job and her young son–but Hitler’s invasion of Ukraine and Russia sends her on a different path. Given a rifle and sent to join the fight, Mila must forge herself

from studious girl to deadly sniper–a lethal hunter of Nazis known as Lady Death. When news of her three hundredth kill makes her a national heroine, Mila finds herself torn from the bloody battlefields of the eastern front and sent to America on a goodwill tour.

Still reeling from war wounds and devastated by loss, Mila finds herself isolated and lonely in the glittering world of Washington, DC–until an unexpected friendship with First Lady Eleanor Roosevelt and an even more unexpected connection with a silent fellow sniper offer the possibility of happiness. But when an old enemy from Mila’s past joins forces with a deadly new foe lurking in the shadows, Lady Death finds herself battling her own demons and enemy bullets in the deadliest duel of her life.

Based on a true story, The Diamond Eye is a haunting novel of heroism born of desperation, of a mother who became a soldier, of a woman who found her place in the world and changed the course of history forever.

Book Summary

The Diamond Eye follows the life of Lyudmila “Mila” Pavlichenko across two timelines: her wartime experiences in the Soviet Union and her propaganda tour of the United States in 1942. The American narrative is told from three perspectives: Mila, Eleanor Roosevelt, and an anonymous American sniper plotting to frame Mila for the president’s assassination.


The Past: From Student to Sniper

The novel delves into Mila’s past, beginning in 1937. A 21-year-old single mother, Mila is determined to prove her worth to her estranged, manipulative husband, Alexei, who refuses to grant her a divorce. She hones her sharpshooting skills, finding solace in its clear-cut rules and precision. In 1941, the German invasion shatters her life as a history student. She enlists to protect her son’s future, quickly distinguishing herself as an exceptional sniper. Despite facing skepticism from some officers, she becomes famous for her skill, befriending a medic, Lena Paliy, and a fellow sniper, Kostia Shevelyov. She also falls in love with a dashing lieutenant, Lyonya Kitsenko, who respects her as both a soldier and a woman. Her relationships with Kostia and Lyonya are a sharp contrast to her turbulent one with Alexei, who becomes increasingly jealous of her new life.


The Present: The American Tour

The wartime narrative is interspersed with Mila’s 1942 trip to the United States. She is uncomfortable with the American public’s fascination with a female sniper. A mysterious American sniper, believing her fame to be a fabrication, plans to frame her for an assassination. He decides she will be an easy target after watching her give a speech. Meanwhile, Mila bonds with Eleanor Roosevelt, who helps her realize she has been afraid to take risks in her personal life.

Lyonya is tragically killed, and Mila is wounded and evacuated. She is then ordered on a propaganda tour, with the manipulative Alexei as her unwanted escort. She asks for Kostia to join them as an interpreter, and their bond deepens. Kostia confesses his love for her, and she begins to envision a life with him. The American sniper, now posing as an admirer named William Jonson, grows more obsessed with her, giving her diamond jewelry as part of his ruse. After a shooting demonstration, he realizes she is a legitimate threat and plans to use Alexei to carry out his plan.


The Final Confrontation

On her last night in Washington, Mila’s sniper instincts kick in. She recognizes Jonson’s specific mannerisms, confirming he is a fellow sniper. She tracks him to his nest, luring him out with the diamonds she places on a dummy. She shoots him before he realizes her trap. Alexei, desperate to hide his involvement, tries to kill Mila, but she kills him first, finally freeing herself from his control.

Mila proposes to Kostia, who decides to stay with her in America. The novel ends with Mila happily reunited with her son, ready to write her memoirs and share her story, even as she protects certain parts of her past.

About the author

Kate Quinn is the New York Times and USA Today bestselling author of historical fiction. A native of southern California, she attended Boston University where she earned a Bachelor’s and Master’s degree in Classical Voice. She has written four novels in the Empress of Rome Saga, and two books in the Italian Renaissance, before turning to the 20th century with “The Alice Network”, “The Huntress,” “The Rose Code,” and “The Diamond Eye.” All have been translated into multiple languages. Kate and her husband now live in San Diego with three rescue dogs.

Other books from Kate:

A beautiful blue-blooded debutante, a tart-tongued London shop-girl, and a shy crossword-solving spinster join the war against Nazi Germany as codebreakers of Bletchley Park, only to find that the real puzzle lies inside the Park itself as a traitor sets them against each other in a betrayal reaching past the end of the war.

A breathtaking epic novel illuminating the hopes, desires, and destinies of princesses and peasants, harlots and wives, fanatics and philosophers—six unforgettable women whose paths cross during one of the most tumultuous and transformative events in history: the French Revolution.

A fascinating historical novel about a battle-haunted English journalist and a Russian female bomber pilot who join forces to track the Huntress, a Nazi war criminal gone to ground in America.

Two women—a female spy recruited to the real-life Alice Network in France during World War I and an unconventional American socialite searching for her cousin in 1947—are brought together in a mesmerizing story of courage and redemption.

  • A Day of Fire: A Novel of Pompeii – Book 1

Pompeii was a lively resort flourishing in the shadow of Mount Vesuvius at the height of the Roman Empire. When Vesuvius erupted in an explosion of flame and ash, the entire town would be destroyed. Some of its citizens died in the chaos, some escaped the mountain’s wrath . . . and these are their stories

  • A Year of Ravens: A Novel of Boudica – Book 2

Britannia: land of mist and magic clinging to the western edge of the Roman Empire. A red-haired queen named Boudica led her people in a desperate rebellion against the might of Rome, an epic struggle destined to consume heroes and cowards, young and old, Roman and Celt . . . and these are their stories.

  • A Song of War: A Novel of Troy – Book 3

Troy: city of gold, gatekeeper of the east, haven of the god-born and the lucky, a city destined to last a thousand years. But the Fates have other plans—the Fates, and a woman named Helen. In the shadow of Troy’s gates, all must be reborn in the greatest war of the ancient world: slaves and queens, heroes and cowards, seers and kings . . . and these are their stories.

  • Lady of the Eternal City

Fourth volume in the Empress of Rome series, an unforgettable new tale of the politics, power, and passion that defined ancient Rome.

  • The Three Fates

Beloved Emperor Trajan is dead. His brutal successor Hadrian draws ever nearer to Rome. And three desperate souls try to forge new paths in a world turned upside down . . .

  • Empress of Seven Hills

Powerful, prosperous, and expanding ever farther into the untamed world, the Roman Empire has reached its zenith under the rule of the beloved Emperor Trajan. But neither Trajan nor his reign can last forever…

  • Mistress of Rome

Thea is a slave girl from Judaea, purchased as a toy for the spiteful heiress Lepida Pollia. Now she has infuriated her mistress by capturing the attention of Rome’s newest and most savage gladiator—and though his love brings Thea the first happiness of her life, their affair ends quickly when a jealous Lepida tears them apart.

Buy the book here: The diamond eye

Visit Kate’s website: https://www.katequinnauthor.com/

About the main character - LYUDMILA PAVLICHENKO 'LADY DEATH'

'IF WE CATCH YOU, WE WILL TEAR YOU INTO 309 PIECES AND SCATTER THEM TO THE WINDS!

Born in present-day Ukraine in 1916, Lyudmila Pavlichenko fought for the Red Army during WW2 and became the deadliest female sniper in history. Known as ‘Lady Death’, her name struck fear into the hearts of German soldiers. Her reputation on the frontline was warranted with 309 confirmed kills to her name, racked up in just a matter of months – a number placing her amongst the greatest snipers of all time.

Justice Robert Jackson, Lyudmila Pavlichenko and Eleanor Roosevelt in 1942. Library of Congress

Russian delegates accompany Pavlichenko (right) on her visit to Washington, D.C. in 1942. Library of Congress.

🥃 Drink Pairings for The Diamond Eye

Each drink matches a mood, a moment, or a setting from the book.

Vodka on the Rocks — The Soldier’s Toast When Mila and her comrades are huddled in the frozen trenches of Sevastopol, there is only one drink. Simple, sharp, no ceremony. A single shot of good Russian or Ukrainian vodka, ice cold, drunk in one go. That’s the Eastern Front in a glass.

Horilka with Honey (Medova) — Kyiv, 1937 Ukraine’s traditional spirit, softened with honey, is what Mila’s quieter, bookish life in Kyiv tastes like warm underneath, with an unexpected bite. Look for a Ukrainian horilka or substitute a honey whiskey if you can’t find it.

Black Russian — Lady Death’s Shadow Vodka and coffee liqueur, dark and serious, no frills. The drink of a woman who has seen things she cannot unsee, sitting in a Washington hotel room far from home. Strong, brooding, and deceptively smooth.

Champagne Cocktail — The White House Dinner Mila at a glittering Washington reception, surrounded by pearls and evening gowns, completely out of her element. A classic champagne cocktail sugar cube, a dash of bitters, topped with bubbles is the drink of that world. Pretty on the surface. Complicated underneath.

Sweet Tea with Lemon — Eleanor’s Parlor For the readers who don’t drink, or for the afternoons that call for something gentler: Eleanor Roosevelt was famous for her warm, unassuming hospitality. A tall glass of iced sweet tea, with lemon, is exactly what their unlikely friendship feels like.

Espresso, Straight — Kostia’s Energy Dark, silent, necessary. No sugar. Just pure focus. That’s Kostia in a cup and honestly, the drink to have in your hand during the final chapters when the tension is absolutely unbearable.

The map above traces Mila’s entire extraordinary journey — from the snowbound streets of Kyiv to the Black Sea coast, and all the way to the corridors of American power. Here’s a quick guide to each stop:

Kyiv, Ukraine — Start at the Ukrainian Motherland Monument and its WWII museum, one of the most moving in all of Eastern Europe. This is the world Mila was born into and the country she bled for. Then walk toward the Arch of Freedom, near the old university district where she studied history — look out over the Dnipro and imagine a 21-year-old with a borrowed rifle and an uncertain future.

Odesa, Ukraine — The Siege of Odesa is where Mila first proved herself as a sniper. The Odessa Archaeological Museum captures the deep, layered history of this port city — a city that refused to fall quietly.

Sevastopol, Crimea — The bloodiest section of the novel unfolds here during the Battle of Sevastopol. The Monument to the Sunken Ships stands at the harbor’s edge, a hauntingly beautiful symbol of a city that has known war across centuries. Stand at the waterfront and let the weight of it settle.

Washington, D.C. — The White House, where a Soviet sniper in a dress shook hands with the President of the United States. Possibly the most surreal stop on any book trail, anywhere.

Hyde Park, New York — Eleanor Roosevelt’s Val-Kill cottage is the hidden gem of this trail. Warm, unpretentious, and quietly powerful — just like the woman herself, and just like the friendship she built with Mila. It’s open to visitors and free to enter the grounds.

Book Club discussion questions:

  1. What is your opinion on Mila’s capacity to focus on a snipper mission and put a side her relationships, her son and family?
  2. Do you think she enjoys being a snipper, why?
  3. Team Kostia or Team Lyonya?
  4. Does bring more to the story ready about “My memoir my official version, versus My memoir the unofficial version?
  5. In society today, do you think women are still discriminate in certain job roles?
  6. Did you find adequate what Mila said to Eleanour Rossevelt at the first breakfast, “Do you look into the eyes of the people you kill”
  7. What are your thoughts on her husband Alexei?
  8. What are your thoughts on the relationship of Mila and her father?

TRIVIA Questions:

  • What is the name of the ballet dancer who drives tanks in the novel?
  • In what year does Eleanour R. goes to Russia?
  • The gift Mila receives in Chicago, what was it?
  • Who is the love of her life?
  • Who dedicated a song to Miss Pavlichenko?
  • What Slavka study after the war?
  • What did she dedicate her life on after the war?
  • What were the teachings of the old Vracka?
  • How does Alexei used to call her?

Character Anaylsis

Lyudmila Pavlichenko

Lyudmila Pavlichenko is the novel’s protagonist and narrator. The story follows her journey from a young single mother and history student to a world-famous sniper. Initially, Mila is defined by her past mistakes, particularly a failed marriage, which motivates her to seek perfection in her shooting. Her obsession with marksmanship is a way to prove her worth to herself and her son. However, as she becomes a legendary sniper, she maintains her humanity, refusing to tally her kills and fighting only to protect her country and loved ones. After experiencing profound loss in the war, her journey becomes one of healing and self-acceptance. By the end of the novel, Mila has fully embraced her identity as a hero, a woman, and a mother, finding confidence and happiness with her new family.


Alexei Pavlichenko

Alexei Pavlichenko is Mila’s first husband and a controlling, manipulative man. He is a surgeon who seduced a young Mila, then abandoned her and their son. He is obsessed with conventional masculinity and views Mila as an object to be dominated, not as an equal. He is deeply jealous of her success and her relationships with other men, particularly Lyonya and Kostia. His ego and misogyny ultimately lead him to ally with the American sniper. In a final act of rage, he attempts to kill Mila to prevent her from revealing his part in the plot, but she kills him in self-defense, finally freeing herself from his control.


The American Sniper

The unnamed American sniper is one of the novel’s three narrators. He is a fictional character hired to assassinate President Roosevelt and frame Mila. He is a contrast to Mila’s character: he kills for profit while she kills for patriotism. Initially, he dismisses Mila as a “trick pony” and a mere propaganda tool, underestimating her skills because she is a woman. His misogyny, like Alexei’s, is his fatal flaw. After he realizes she is a true sharpshooter, his mission becomes a personal vendetta. In their final confrontation, he continues to underestimate her, and Mila uses his ego against him, ultimately outsmarting and killing him.


Kostia Shevelyov

Kostia Shevelyov is Mila’s sniper partner and eventual husband. He is a skilled hunter and a loyal friend who is uncomfortable with most people but shares a deep intellectual and philosophical connection with Mila. Unlike other men in her life, he respects her intellect and her choices. Though he secretly loves her, he accepts her relationship with Lyonya, telling her she “picked the best man.” Kostia is a key figure in her journey to happiness; his willingness to stay with her and his understanding of her full identity—including her academic aspirations—shows his genuine love and respect.


Lyonya Kitsenko

Lyonya Kitsenko is Mila’s regimental commander and a worthy romantic partner. In contrast to Alexei, he is kind, dashing, and respects Mila’s skills as a sniper. He is a hero who saves her life and comforts her in times of fear. Their relationship is a symbol of hope and a stepping stone in Mila’s journey to accept love and happiness. His tragic death is a pivotal moment that forces Mila to confront the unpredictability of life and resolve not to let fear of loss hold her back from a future with Kostia.


Lena Paliy

Lena Paliy is Mila’s first friend at the front. The two women instantly bond over their shared patriotism and mutual experiences. Lena is a source of comfort and support for Mila throughout her wartime injuries and celebrated fame. She encourages Mila to embrace a wartime romance, and their enduring friendship highlights the importance of female bonds in a brutal wartime environment.


Eleanor Roosevelt

Eleanor Roosevelt is a prominent figure in the novel, representing American ideals and feminism. Despite their different backgrounds, she and Mila form a strong bond. Eleanor shows compassion for Mila’s losses and encourages her to be more forgiving of her own flaws. Her friendship helps Mila gain self-confidence. Their relationship, which culminates in Mila saving the president, becomes one of mutual respect and equality, underscoring the novel’s theme of friendship.


Franklin Delano Roosevelt

Franklin D. Roosevelt, or FDR, is the president of the United States and the target of the assassination plot. His primary role is to symbolize Allied victory and the hope for American involvement in the war. The novel highlights his physical vulnerability due to his illness, but also his personal strength in concealing his disability. His last words to Mila, a promise of American support, reinforce the novel’s themes of patriotism and alliance.